The Federal High Court sitting in Abeokuta has ruled in favour of Adron Homes and Properties Limited, dismissing a fundamental rights suit filed by the Registered Trustees of the City of David Residents Association (CODRA) and five others.
In Suit No. FHC/AB/FHR/58/2023, presided over by Justice Abiodun J. Adeyemi, the applicants — Elder Gbadebo Aromolaran, Mr. Adetokunbo Adeshile, Mr. Olaolu Ayinde, Olusegun Aba Yomi Esq, and Oluwadamilare Awokoya Esq — accused Adron Homes of infringing on their right to personal liberty.
However, after a detailed review of submissions and evidence, Justice Adeyemi ruled that the allegations were “speculative, unsubstantiated, and without merit.” The court found no proof that Adron Homes had taken any action, such as arrest or detention, that could amount to a breach of the applicants’ fundamental rights.
On the issue of freedom of association, the court clarified that while residents are free to form and join associations, the legal authority to own, manage, and administer the estate remains solely with Adron Homes as the rightful developer. The court also emphasized that Adron Homes has no legal power to proscribe CODRA or prevent residents from associating among themselves.
Justice Adeyemi noted that the judgment was based strictly on evidence and applicable law, not conjecture or sentiment, and accordingly dismissed the case in its entirety.
Adron Homes welcomed the decision, describing it as a landmark judgment that vindicates its position as a law-abiding, customer-focused developer committed to safeguarding the interests of residents.